Email not displaying correctly? View it in your browser. Or print it.
Contact Us Issue 5, 1 May - 30 Jun 2008  
FOCUS: May - June 2008
In This Issue of the Child Rights Monitor
 Killing and maiming
 Detention
 Cruel, inhumane and degrading treatment
 Forced displacement
 Attacks on educational and health facilities
 Denial of humanitarian access

Killing and maiming

Killings

During the reporting period 16 Palestinian children were killed in the occupied Palestinian territory (oPt): 12 of them were killed by the Israeli military and four as a result of Palestinian mishandling of weapons. Of the 12 children killed by the Israeli military, eight were not taking direct part in hostilities at the time they were killed and in one additional case the circumstances remain unclear. 
 
Most of the children killed (13) were in the Gaza Strip and most of them (13) were boys. The youngest child was 6 years old; she was killed by Israeli artillery fire in front of her house in Khan Younis on 11 June.
Distribution of Palestinian child fatalities according to month by perpetrator
  Jan   Feb Mar  Apr  May  Jun  Total 
Israeli military  10 10  29 21  4  82
Palestinian groups  0  2  1  1  1  3  8
 Total  10  12  30  22  9  7  90
The period between 1 May and 30 June registered the lowest levels of child fatalities since the start of 2008 after having reached unprecedented levels during the previous reporting period following operation Warm Winter in Gaza. However, the month of June saw a relatively sharp increase in child fatalities since the start of the year due to internal Palestinian violence. 
 
Injuries
A total of 58 Palestinian children were injured by the Israeli military during this reporting period. The majority of injuries (44 or 73 per cent) took place in the West Bank. About half of the injuries occurring in the West Bank (21) took place during anti-Wall demonstrations, including 19 injured by rubber-coated metal bullets fired by the Israeli military at protestors in Ni’lin. Furthermore, two Palestinian children were injured, along with their mother, when a rocket fired from east of Gaza City towards Sderot hit their family home in Gaza. [UNOCHA]
 
In addition, two children were injured in Nablus and Hebron governorates by stones thrown by Israeli settlers. [UNOCHA]
One Israeli child was injured by a rocket fired from the Gaza Strip in May 2008. No Israeli children were killed during the reporting period. [UNOCHA]
A 13-year-old child from Tulkarem refugee camp was injured by Israeli unexploded ordnance on 7 June; his left foot was amputated and he lost vision in his right eye. [DCI/PS]
Detention

Number of Palestinian children in Israeli detention by month
2008
Male
Female
 Total
January
325
2
327
February
305
2
307
March
322
3
325
April
323
4
327
May
334
3
337
June
317
6
323
It is estimated that the number of Palestinian children being held in Israeli prisons and detention / interrogation centres decreased from 337 at the end of May to 323 at the end of June 2008, representing a 4 per cent decrease. However, the number of children held in administrative detention (without charge on trial) has increased from 10 at the end of May, to 13 at the end of June. By the end of June 2008, the number of girls in detention had doubled since the corresponding period in May 2008 (from three to six). [DCI/PS]

In 2008, DCI/PS represented approximately one third of the Palestinian children appearing before the Military Courts. Between May and June 2008, DCI/PS lawyers received 19 new cases, and closed 15 cases (all sentenced). Among the 15 children sentenced during the period, 6 were refugee children; the youngest child was 13 years old.

Among the cases closed, three children were given prison sentences of three years or more; five received sentences of 12-36 months; two received sentences of 6-12 months, and five were given under-six month prison sentences. The majority (10) was aged 16-17; one was aged 12-13.

Breakdown of cases closed by DCI/PS by charge

Charge Number
Conspiracy to murder 3
Stone throwing 5
Throwing/possessing bombs 1
Making/throwing Molotov cocktails 3
Membership in Palestinian political organisation 1
Shooting with machine gun 0
Possession of weapon 2
Attempted murder 0
Total 15

 

Note: Children often receive multiple charges; only one charge - the most serious charge - has been retained in the table for statistical purposes.

Thirteen children were held in administrative detention at the end of June, compared to 10 at the end of May.

As previously documented in the Child Rights Monitor (Issue 2), one of these children is Obaidah, detained since 23 May 2007 and serving his third administrative detention order. He is accused of assisting a member of Islamic Jihad in Syria. [DCI/PS]
 
Cruel, inhumane and degrading treatment

A total of five reports of children being tortured/abused during arrest or interrogation by the Israeli army were received during the reporting period. Four of these cases occurred in the Qalqiliya Governorate while one case took place in the Hebron Governorate in the West Bank. [DCI/PS]

  • In the Qalqiliya Governorate, a 10-year-old boy reported that he had been physically abused by Israeli soldiers for two and a half hours on 11 June. The soldiers were reportedly looking for a pistol they said belonged to his father. The boy told DCI/PS that the soldiers repeatedly hit him in the head and stomach, forced him to hold a stressful position for half an hour, and threatened to assault family members if he did not co-operate. The boy said he had suffered from shock and injuries as a result of the assault. [DCI/PS]
     
  • In the Hebron Governorate, DCI/PS received a statement from a 17-year-old boy reporting that he was shot in the leg and arrested by Israeli soldiers on 9 June. The boy reported that he was subsequently denied family visits, threatened with physical abuse by interrogators, and placed in solitary confinement for six days. [DCI/PS]
Forced displacement

The trend of home demolitions in Jerusalem and the buffer zone in Gaza has continued as seen in previous months: 25 persons, including 15 children, were reported displaced during May and June 2008 – all in East Jerusalem (demolitions occurred in Gaza as well, but displacement figures are still unavailable – see below). By comparison, 29 persons were displaced in the month of April and 275 persons were displaced during February and March.

Numbers of children displaced in all OPT
Jan Feb Mar Apr May Jun Total

100*

33 95 14 3 12

Minimum: 157
Estimate: 257

Note: As displacement is difficult to monitor precisely, figures represent the minimum number of displaced children. Actual figures are likely to be higher.

*Estimate. The total number of displaced persons for January was over 200. As children constitute over 50% of the Palestinians population, the number of children displaced in January is likely to be quite high. [OCHA]

In Gaza, 11 houses were demolished in five separate military incursions in the border areas of Khan Yunis and Rafah. The number of persons displaced as a result of these demolitions is as yet unknown.

Although no homes were demolished in Palestinian communities located within Israeli-controlled Area C during the reporting period, there is considerable concern regarding the hundreds of stop-work and eviction orders currently being processed within the legal system; all of which could lead to actual demolitions in Palestinian communities within Area C. During the reporting period, 30 additional stop-work and eviction orders were issued to residential structures in East Jerusalem and Palestinian communities within Area C across the West Bank. The southern part of Hebron district has been notably targeted during May and June 2008: ten demolition orders were issued in the Palestinian village of Idhna alone, as well as in At Tuwani, Khirbet Al Jawaya and Umm Faggarah.

In addition, 207 persons in the community of Arab ar-Ramadin, which already has many outstanding demolition orders (the latest demolitions occurring in March 2008), were threatened with forced eviction by the Israel military in early June. The reason cited was that the community needed to move to the other side of the barrier for which construction is currently taking place in the area.

Attacks on educational and health facilities

Attacks on educational facilities

The number of attacks on schools saw a sharp increase from previous months – a total of nine incidents affecting at least 14 schools were recorded in May-June. This compares to three attacks in April and eight recorded for the period February to March.

Seven attacks occurred in the West Bank. This included the IDF occupying the roof of an UNRWA boy’s school in El Fara Camp to use as a shooting position which resulted in injury to one child.

Settlers attacked schools on two occasions during the reporting period, one of which targeted the Ibrahimi boys' school in Hebron, a frequent target of settlers in the H2 area of Hebron, resulting in injury to a teacher and a student.

The IDF attacked and forcibly broke into three schools in Nablus, damaging the main doors of the schools.

The three remaining attacks occurred in Gaza. Two of these targeted Christian institutions: unknown perpetrators detonated a bomb in one incident and in another incident, broke into a school, physically assaulted the school guards and stole property. This school, the El Manara School was previously targeted by unknown gunmen on 21 February 2008. The IDF also broke into and raided a secondary school in central Gaza during a military incursion on 22 May 2008. [OCHA; PCHR] 

Attacks on medical facilities

On 20 June the IDF raided and damaged equipment in a medical centre in Beit Ummar (Hebron).

Raids and closures of Islamic charities

During the reporting period, the Israeli Defense Forces continued the targeting of Islamic charities under the pretense of affiliation with Hamas.

On 5 June, the IDF conducted raids on two Islamic charities associated with the Islamic Charitable Society and issued three-year closure orders to both of them.  Both charities are located in Hebron, one in Al Shuyukh and the other in Beit Ula. In both incidents, computers and files were confiscated and furniture was damaged extensively.

The Al Shuyukh location oversees one school and one kindergarten, which are attended by 400 children. Al Shuyukh also supports 500 orphans with free education, clothing and food. The Beit Ula location manages two schools and three kindergartens, which are attended by 930 children, and supports 400 orphans. 

The closure orders do not clarify whether the three schools and four kindergartens managed by the organisations, are affected.

Denial of humanitarian access

Access to education

Fewer disruptions to education were recorded in May-June than in preceding months. However, on 1 and 3 May, schools in the West Bank village of Azzun were closed as a result of curfews imposed by the Israeli military. Also in Azzun, on 12 May, only a limited number of students were able to attend school following a curfew imposed during the day.

Minimum number of schools with at least one day of disruption
  Jan Feb Mar Apr May Jun Total
WB 15 19 43 11 1 0 89
GS n/a n/a n/a n/a n/a n/a n/a
Total 15 19 43 11 1 0 89

Note: The school year ended in June and the Palestinian Ministry of Education cancelled all government-sponsored summer camps citing financial difficulty

In addition, the IDF blockade on the village of Ni'lin (imposed after villagers protested the requisitioning and isolation of 2,500 dunums of their land for construction of the wall) prevented children from reaching their schools on 29 May.

Access to health care

Two children were reported to have died after delay in access to vital health care during the reporting period.

In Gaza, a 13 year-old-girl with brain cancer received the approval of the Israeli authorities to receive life saving treatment in Israel on 28 March 2008. However on the day of her exit, she was denied passage through Erez as the ambulance that was to transport her did not clear the coordination procedure. The girl died on 5 May 2008.

Number of child fatalities due to restricted access to healthcare
Jan Feb Mar Apr May Jun Total
1 1 1 0 1 1 5


A 17-year-old girl with brain cancer received the approval of the Israeli authorities to receive life saving treatment in Israel on 9 March 2008. After waiting for four hours at the Erez crossing to be interviewed by a security officer her companion was denied access. The girl returned to Gaza and applied for another permit this time to go to Egypt. The girl received approval to enter Egypt for the same life saving treatment. She died on 17 June after being unable to cross the closed Rafah border [WHO].

Design by C. Seitz

The Child Rights Monitor, a bi-monthly report produced by Defence for Children International-Palestine (DCI/PS) and Save the Children UK (SCUK), provides up-to-date information on the rights of Palestinian children affected by armed conflict in the occupied Palestinian territory (oPt), indicates trends, and makes recommendations.

Where does the information come from? 

Information is put together from reports produced by the Israel/oPt Working Group on Security Council Resolution 1612 on Children and Armed Conflict, which includes: UNICEF, UNOCHA, UNRWA, OHCHR, WHO, B'Tselem, DCI/PS and SCUK.

The Child Rights Monitor disseminates information produced by this Working Group along with additional data produced and/or collected by DCI/PS and SCUK.

Each issue includes updated information on each child rights violation, cases studies, recommendations, and links to recent reports relating to Israeli or Palestinian children affected by the armed conflict and the occuaption.

About UN Security Council Resolution 1612 

UN Security Council Resolution 1612 on Children and Armed Conflict, adopted in July 2005, established a monitoring, reporting and compliance mechanism on six grave child rights violations occurring in conflict:

- killing or maiming;
- recruitment or use of children;
- sexual abuse;
- abduction;
- attacks against schools or hospitals;
- denial of humanitarian access.

The Israel/oPt monitoring and reporting mechanism (MRM) was established in April 2007, and reports on the six violations above, as well as detention, torture and forced displacement.

The MRM includes UN agencies and non-governmental organisations, and reports every two months to a working group mandated to make recommendations to the Security Council.

These recommendations can include the imposition, through country-specific resolutions, of “targeted and graduated measures.”
 

Education in Israeli prisons 

The Israeli Prison Service (IPS) provides limited education to child detainees in two out of the five prisons where Palestinian children are held whereas no education is provided in the seven interrogation and detention centres where children can be detained for up to seven months. Where permitted, educational instruction is provided for two and nine hours respectively and is limited to the teaching of Arabic, Hebrew, English and mathematics. For security reasons, only some science education is allowed. The children are provided with workbooks and pens during class times only, but are not allowed to keep these materials once the classes have concluded. There is no provision of education to female child detainees [DCI/PS]

Two girls in administrative detention 

Two girls were given administrative detention orders in June. Both girls are aged 16 years. The girls were arrested by the Israeli Security Agency (Shin Beit) on the same night. The explanation given for their detention is that they have been involved in militant activities (“endangering the security of the area” according to the military Administrative Detention Order, issued on 12 June 2008). However, no charges have been made against them. Neither of the girls have been arrested before. Both girls are now in Addamoun prison in Israel and are being held with adult Palestinian female detainees. Neither of the girls have been allowed any contact with their families since their arrest on 5 June 2008. Their administrative detention orders have been set for four and five months, with the possibility of an up to 6-month renewal at the end of that period. Administrative detention orders can be renewed indefinitely. [DCI/PS]

Unreported case of cruel, inhumane and degrading treatment from previous reporting period 

A 14-year-old boy from Biddu who had been arrested in February 2008 was released in June and met with a DCI/PS lawyer. He reported being physically assaulted by Israeli soldiers who hit his head with the butts of their guns, sprayed his face with tear-gas and was accused of throwing stones towards the Barrier. Bleeding from wounds sustained during his arrest the boy was said he was coerced into signing papers written in Hebrew (which he does not read or speak) in which he confessed to throwing stones at the Barrier. An Israeli Military Court accepted this confession and sentenced the boy to four and-a-half months’ imprisonment. [DCI/PS]

Recommendations 
  • All parties should immediately revise their rules of engagement to expressly forbid attacks on schools, or the use of schools for military purposes, in line with international humanitarian and human rights law principles;
     
  • Israeli authorities should undertake the independent investigation and prosecution of Israeli civilians, in particular paramilitary groups, involved in violent acts against children;

  • All authorities should refrain from using any acts of cruel, inhuman or degrading treatment against children during arrest, transfer, detention and interrogation in accordance with international law, Israeli Military Courts should not accept evidence obtained under duress, through physical abuse, threat or trickery;

  • All parties to the conflict, including the Israeli army and security services, the Palestinian Authority, Hamas and Palestinian armed groups, must ensure that no children are recruited or used in the conflict, whether forcefully or voluntarily;

  • Israel must end the inconsistency between the international definition of “child” as stipulated in the UN Convention on the Rights of the Child (i.e. under the age of 18) and as applied by the Israeli authorities to Israeli children, and the definition of a Palestinian child under Military Order 132 (i.e. a person under the age of 16);

  • As Israel retains effective control of Gaza, it remains an occupying power and as such, must accept its responsibility for the welfare of Gaza’s civilian population and put an end to punitive measures that deny essential goods and services to the civilian population of Gaza. These measures constitute collective punishment and are contrary to international humanitarian and human rights law;

  • As a matter of urgency Israel must ensure that Gaza-based Palestinian patients in need of critical or lifesaving medical care have immediate and unimpeded access to healthcare facilities outside Gaza;

  • All parties must resume full coordination with authorities in Gaza to facilitate the import of essential items.
Updates and reports 

DCI/PS: Military Court Updates: Reports 1-7, 9 June 2008

DCI/PS: Israeli military continues to torture Palestinian children, Press release on International Day against Torture, 26 June 2008
Public Committee Against Torture in Israel (PCATI): No Defense: Soldier Violence against Palestinian Detainees, Periodic Report (June 2008)
UNOCHA: Humanitarian Monitor, No. 25 (May 2008)
 
UNOCHA: Humanitarian Monitor, No. 26 (June 2008)
 
 
The Guardian:  Video documentary: 'They say they have the right to shoot at us and kill us' (15 May)
The Guardian: Video documentary: ‘Gaza's children suffer as conflict enters the classroom’ (16 May)
Coalition to Stop the Use of Child Soldiers: 2008 Global Report, OPT entry (20 May)
Contact us 

Child Rights Monitor Website: www.childrightsmonitor.org
Email: crm@list.childrightsmonitor.org

Defence for Children International - Palestine Section (DCI/PS)
PO Box 55201, Jerusalem
Tel:  +972 2 242 7537 
Web: www.dci-pal.org
Contact person:
Isabelle Guitard
isabelle@dci-pal.org
 
Save the Children UK
PO Box 18117, Jerusalem 91180
Tel:  +972 2 583-8594 
Web: www.savethechildren.org.uk
Contact person:
Jennifer Moorehead
jennifer_scpal@palnet.com
You are subscribed to the Monitor list produced by DCI/PS and Save the Children UK.

To unsubscribe, write to listsrv@list.childrightsmonitor.org with "Unsubscribe monitor" in the body of the email.

To subscribe, write to listsrv@list.childrightsmonitor.org with "Subscribe monitor" in the body of the email.